Citizen Science Under the Spotlight – by Dave Donald

If you’re a passionate fisho and are concerned about the future of our fishery, then you should look to become involved in some citizen science. How do I do that you might ask? Well, there are a myriad of ways to participate, from simply starting a personal log of your fishing trips through to engaging in fish tagging or volunteering for habitat rebuilding projects via organizations such as OzFish. Today’s digital age offers opportunities to record and analyse our fishing activities to a degree that is unprecedented, adding another facet to the enjoyment of our lifestyle choice. 

The recreational fishing sector has always had a credibility problem when species management is being developed due to the lack of robust data regarding catch levels made by participants. This has led in many cases to rampant speculation by government entities as to the impact of recreational fishing on the resources of our major target species, a factor that can influence how restrictive bag limits are applied to our catches. Fisheries Queensland have almost always leaned toward capping recreational catches before adjusting commercial quota’s, a bias that is unable to be questioned due to the absence of any credible data from the non-commercial side.

Many of us, particularly those from the pre digital age, are extremely wary of sharing personal information even though we are aware of being ‘mined’ to an extent never before seen in our lifetime. The intricacies of our lives are an open book, it seems, with Big Brother learning more about us almost every day, now going as far as recognizing an individual’s face! The most concerning development here is that digital technology can be used for bad – as well as good – and that dichotomy inevitably leads to an erosion of trust in those entities accumulating any data we supply.

Fisheries Queensland are currently actively promoting their QLD Fishing 2.0 app which, in part, asks participants to record their catches. This should be an opportunity for all recreational fishers to become involved in a citizen science project of significant value to our state’s fisheries management but can we be confident that any data collected will be used in a positive, proactive manner? Herein lies a massive roadblock to what should be a landmark fisheries citizen science project. Can Fisheries Queensland be trusted to use the data collected to achieve an equitable outcome in terms of the sectors involved – commercial, recreational, indigenous and environmental? Their actions to date have been far from encouraging!

How about we take a look at some existing examples involving citizen science to get an idea of how they perform? 

Arguably one of the leading CS projects in the world today happens right here in Queensland under the SUNTAG banner. This enormous data base containing information on more than one million tagged fish was born in the mid 1980’s by Queensland members of the Australian National Sportfishing Association (ANSA) with Bill Sawynok as coordinator. I was one of the first group of fishers involved in that ground breaking project, eventually placing numbered bits of plastic into upwards of 8,000 fish over a 35 year period. Recaptures included one fingermark (spotted scale sea perch) that was caught and released 3 times over 4 years before being kept.

During the four decades it has been running, SUNTAG’s database has evolved into a behemoth documenting the dynamics of a cross section of Australia’s major sport fish species, publishing comprehensive annual dashboards that provide unprecedented insights into stock movements and levels. Such a comprehensive multi species analysis over a similar time frame would effectively be economically impossible under regularly funded scientific regimens – we’re talking hundreds of millions of dollars worth of historic data produced on a shoestring budget courtesy of hundreds of volunteers willing to tag and release their catches in the name of science.

Around the same time the tagging program happened, my initial foray into the then unidentified realm of citizen science centred around keeping a log of my days on the water as a charter skipper, after purchasing the 8 metre Shark Cat ‘Bluefin’ based out of Yeppoon circa 1984. In those days, ‘electronics’ were restricted to a Furuno paper sounder plus HF and CB radios. Navigation essentially involved lining up landmarks, dead reckoning or stumbling over new country. To record waypoints, my daily journal included of sketches of the landmarks used, the actual paper tracings of bottom structure, daily weather conditions and a list of catches made. This was personal citizen science involving tides/moons and seasonal fluctuations but also included shark interactions. These latter details became important when I attended last year’s shark depredation workshop in Townsville, due to the fact that they predated targeted commercial shark fishing and reef fish stocks were only lightly fished. In essence, my logs indicated that our current depredation problems were not present in those relatively unexploited days!

After moving to the Cape in 1989 to become a full-time professional guide, my next move was to develop a template to record daily charter details which by the time I relocated to Weipa in 1997 had evolved into a comprehensive record of statistics that were relevant to a fishing tourism business as well as the usual catch composition, weather etc. These included client details – place of origin, their degree of competency, tackle preference, trip length – as well as crocodile numbers and daily highlights. Over a 10 year period, nearly 3,000 sheets accumulated, a data set later described by a leading independent fisheries scientist as unique and irreplaceable.

In 2011, with financial assistance from the Western Cape Chamber of Commerce, I published a comprehensive 96 page report on the Weipa fishery that included analysis of the log sheet data in terms of yearly catches, both in estuarine and offshore waters. The resulting graphs clearly showed a major decline in numbers of all species over that decade, with offshore catches exhibiting drops as high as 70%. While the report was enthusiastically received by the Chamber and independent scientists, Fisheries Queensland discarded its findings and recommendations as anecdotal, therefore irrelevant. In the years since, two of Albatross Bay’s once most prolific species, tea leaf trevally and longtail tuna have now became rare.

 Some might say I wasted my time, and I get no pleasure from the fact that my data appears to have been robust. However, the self-satisfaction that comes from working towards a better understanding of the marine environment far outweighs the kicks in the guts by the people who are failing to do their job. 

On the positive side, the profile of citizen science is definitely on the rise right across the board these days. 

 One major reason for this is the increasing lack of priority in government circles now given to scientific research. Everywhere you look, funding is being reduced to traditional scientific bodies such as universities and the CSIRO. Involving citizen scientists in research effectively allows the dollar pool to be stretched a bit wider, particularly in labour intensive activities based outdoors, such as marine and remote locations.

There is even an Australian Citizen Science Association that now works with a host of government and conservation entities right around the country.

Therefore, if you’re thinking of investing time in some worthy projects directly impacting recreational fishing, my suggestion would be to become a member of your local fish stocking group or OzFish. Both provide the perfect opportunity to work with like-minded community members while gaining an insight into the practical application of scientific principles. Given the enormous physical damage the marine environment has suffered in the past, OzFish’s amazingly successful rehabilitation of Moreton Bay’s oyster reefs and its ongoing work in stabilization of eroded and de-snagged waterways are very worthy causes indeed.

Heading back to the question of whether or not we should support the QLD Fishing 2.0 app, 

I think that it’s important that we remind Fisheries Queensland that there are major issues here that require comprehensive consultation with recreational fishing stakeholders. 

Ideally, negotiations should happen via a representative peak body that is funded in accordance with our economic contribution – recognized by our current government at $2.4 billion per annum. Until recreational fishers can be confident that they are a major participant in the process and concrete assurances have been given as to the use of the data provided, it’s NO DEAL from me.

But data is only part of our fishing experience! It’s easy to put a data value on fishery product that ends up on the market floor, even to calculate what fishers spend on tackle, boats and bait! But government must seek to understand the intangibles involved and their significant value to the overall community, things like individual mental and physical health, cohesion and cooperation, and exposure to an outdoor lifestyle. 

To reduce the pleasure and satisfaction of going fishing to a data set or an Artificial Intelligence word fest will never come anywhere near duplicating the pleasure of casting a line somewhere. Something so simple, yet so profound! 

Dr Ben Diggles not only works as a paid scientist, he also contributes heavily to citizen science projects. One of his projects, an Iki Jimi App that is free to download, provides specialist knowledge on the brain location of all major species, both physically and via X-ray pictures. The author assisted Ben to catch this king salmon that was subsequently X-rayed to show its brain site.

 

This slab of a barra taken by the author on a Deceiver fly in Peter Faust Dam was the result of volunteers undertaking citizen science – fingerlings released by a community stocking group. After a quick photo, the fish was returned to the water to do it all again (maybe)!

 

John Haenke releases another barra from the same session! Data sets will never replace the thrill of catching fish like this!

 

John Haenke releases another barra from the same session! Data sets will never replace the thrill of catching fish like this!